Brand Storytelling Isn’t Just Important, It’s Absolutely Critical


brand storytelling

Storytelling has been an intrinsic part of what makes us human since there have been humans. From cave paintings and oral traditions to the printing press, radio, television, and the internet, our history as a species is in many ways the history of the evolution of how we tell our stories, and how we communicate. They’re part of who we are.

And that’s why stories are a critical part of your marketing and brand identity. Brand is the story of your business, and emphasizing that story has a lot of benefits for your marketing and for your business as a whole. Let’s break down what brand storytelling is, look at a few examples in the market, and come to a better understanding of why storytelling is critical to your company’s success.

What’s a brand story, and what’s brand storytelling?

Brand story is pretty much exactly what it sounds like—the story of your brand. It describes everything from the inception of the company to the reason it exists and where it wants to go in the future. It’s not simply the names and dates, the history of what you’ve done since your founding. It’s the motivation behind that founding, the “why” behind your existence.

A good example of a brand telling their story well is the socially conscious shoe company TOMS. Their entire story is summed up nicely in a few short sentences:

We’ve always been in business to improve lives. In 2006, TOMS founder Blake Mycoskie pioneered the One for One® model. Since then, our community has had a positive impact on over 100,000,000 lives. Today, we commit 1/3 of our profits for grassroots good, supporting people building equity at the local level, and driving progress from the ground up.

You instantly understand why the company was created, and what they’re fighting for.

Brand storytelling is a little different from your brand’s story. Instead of focusing solely on telling the story of your brand’s history, brand storytelling brings certain brand elements or characteristics to life through storytelling mechanisms.

One example of brand storytelling that helps support a company’s product is Warby Parker’s “How Warby Parker Glasses Are Made.” The video follows a pair of glasses from the beginning stages of design to the final stage of production.



Brand storytelling could be used to help bring your brand story to life, or it could also be used as a way to engage your audience about a certain characteristic of your product or service.

Why does brand storytelling matter?

Humans are wired to tell stories. In every culture across the world, people tell stories. In fact, Time reports on a study in Nature Communications that shows storytelling teaches social norms and fosters social cooperation, and that storytellers themselves improve their chances of being chosen as social partners, receiving community support, and even having healthier offspring.

In this case, the brand is the storyteller and can reap some of those benefits among customers. Here are some other ways storytelling helps your brand.

1. Stories grab attention

As marketers, we tend to realize that we’re interlopers in people’s lives. Very few people actively seek out advertisements. In fact, from the DVR to online ad-blockers, most people are looking for ways to decrease the amount of marketing in their lives. Be that as it may, when you’re trying to run a business you have to get the word out, so we try to find ways to do that while ingratiating ourselves to our audience—or at least trying to make sure they don’t hate us.

Storytelling is one way to do that. People are inherently more interested in reading or watching something fun than they are a string of boasts or a list of stats and features. Yes, once a prospect is interested in your brand those things can help close the deal. But that can’t be what you lead with. Lead with the family whose life is changed because of your RV, or the business owner who becomes a local leader after your product cuts costs in half.

Stories and emotions are a huge part of how we make decisions, so starting with story will pull someone in more quickly than simply telling them you’ll save them money.

2. Stories sell better

Stories don’t just build interest in your brand—that in and of itself would be helpful, as your brand followers can spread the word about your business even if they don’t actually buy anything. But you’re in this for the sales. Luckily, story boosts purchases in addition to building simple interest.

Thinking about sales logically would lead buyers to simply compare the pros and cons of each option in the market and choose the one that best fits their needs. But we all know that’s not how it works. Some buyers ignore the benefits of a superior product in favor of the one their gut directs them toward. Or maybe there are several options that would all be similarly effective, and the buyer simply is forced to make the decision based on other criteria.

This is more common than you might think. For prospects early in your marketing or sales funnel in particular, your story can be what brings them in and gets them to start considering a purchase. Your prospects are buying based at least partly on emotional connection, so if you’re not selling that way you may be falling behind. Storytelling is one way to engage emotionally, meaning that if there’s a story behind your business and brand, you’re likely to start out ahead of the pack when it comes to selling.

Let’s think back to TOMS. If someone reads the story of the company’s mission, they might feel personally motivated to join the mission and story. In this case, the person might actually choose TOMS over a similar competitor because of the company’s story. A quality product helps, but there’s a reason TOMS leads with the good they do in the community.

3. Your story sets you apart

Depending on your industry, there could be many businesses saying roughly the same thing about roughly the same products or services. You could just hope that enough people pick you over the rest so that you can stay in business, but that’s as bad a plan as it sounds. Setting yourself apart from the competition is a must.

One way you can do that is through storytelling. Just like each person has a different life story, every business is unique, even if they appear to share almost all common traits from the outside.

Consider, for example, GEICO and Allstate. As insurance companies, they’re offering roughly the same product: home and auto insurance, primarily. But they’re doing it in very different ways.

GEICO was originally formed to cater to employees of the federal government, but has grown into the second largest auto insurer in the country since opening up to the general public (and inundating Americans with commercials, which we’ll get to).

Allstate was formed as a division of Sears, but is now independent and ranks as the second largest homeowners insurer in the United States. They’re each behemoths of an industry that many people take for granted, so how do they convince people to buy from them rather than the other (or State Farm, or American Family, or Nationwide, etc.)?

how geico and allstate tell their stories

You guessed it—it’s through storytelling. GEICO and Allstate speak to prospects in very different ways, which you likely know if you’ve watched any live or streaming television at all in the past fifteen years. Allstate emphasizes the unpredictability and even danger of life, casting themselves as the ones who can protect us from mayhem. Literally, in their case, with their mascot Mayhem, who ruins everything from tailgates to a Sunday drive to simply parking your car on the street.



According to Allstate, the world is full of danger, but with them, “you’re in good hands.” It’s a little dark, but Winters’ performance as Mayhem is entertaining enough and the situations are extreme enough that the ads are more funny than frightening.

On the other hand, for GEICO it’s all about simplicity and savings. They aren’t talking about everything that can go wrong in your life. It all comes back to one thing: “fifteen minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance.” They don’t make bold claims about their coverage, they simply tell you that it will be easy to get and it will be cheap. And like Allstate, they do it with a bit of style. Actually, a lot of different bits of style—off the top of my head, I can’t think of another major company that has used a wider variety of different sub-campaigns in my lifetime. The gecko, the cavemen, the “hump day” camel, the squealing pig, the rhetorical questions…it’s a lot. But the fact that so many are memorable shows how GEICO’s been able to set themselves apart.



The two insurance giants are selling mostly the same thing, with some details changed. And at the end of the day, those details (the degree of coverage, the cost) may be what solidifies a buyer. But we identify businesses in commoditized industries by their brand—that’s where it starts, where one truly sets itself apart from the rest. No matter the industry or the size of the business, the story you tell makes you unique.

4. Being part of a story is enticing

Everyone wants to be a part of something. Like storytelling, it’s just part of human nature—we’re social animals. So obviously it’s beneficial to leverage that natural impulse when we sell to someone. And storytelling itself is a big part of how we associate with each other. As Pamela B. Rutledge Ph.D., M.B.A., said in Psychology Today, “stories are the pathway to engaging our right brain and triggering our imagination. By engaging our imagination, we become participants in the narrative.”

When we build a story around a brand, it gives the brand the ability to “recruit” prospects to its cause. You’re not just buying a product or a service, in essence you’re joining a team or living a lifestyle. This is true in particular for so-called “lifestyle brands,” which have evolved their brand and story to the point where they’re not selling a product or service as much as they are selling themselves as an experience. Customers aren’t typically buying because the product is the best (though it might be the best), but because it makes them a part of the club. If your brand reaches this point, you’ve basically beaten the final boss of marketing, and you need to protect and cultivate that at all costs.

Nike is a perfect example of a lifestyle brand that customers choose over and over again because they want to be part of the #justdoit culture.

This, of course, doesn’t just apply to recruiting new customers, but also to new employees. No person chooses an employer because they want to feel like a cog in an impersonal machine. They want to be a part of something, fighting for a cause and doing work that really matters. Your brand story provides this meaning, as long as it’s real and not contrived.

When telling stories, say only what you mean

That’s perhaps the most important point: your brand’s story has to be real. You can’t simply invent something from nothing—everyone you’re trying to sell to, from customers and prospects to investors and talent, will see through it. Your story has to reflect something that’s inherently true about your brand, which in turn has to reflect something that’s inherently true about your business. The best way to ensure this is to set the foundations of your brand and story in the personality and history of your founder or your president, or even in your preferred customers.

Whatever your brand, one thing is certain: in today’s crowded landscape, more discerning customers and talent aren’t buying from just anyone. They’re buying where they feel they connect with a brand. Because of that, brand storytelling isn’t just an important part of your business. It’s absolutely critical to your success.

Thomas wears a few hats—writer, editor, and European soccer expert—but his passion is content creation. When he's not crafting thoughtful content, he's coaching high school running, watching the Mets, or talking up Indianapolis to anyone who will listen.

Related resources.

How to Create Role Clarity in your OEM-Dealer Advertising Strategy

How to Create Role Clarity in your OEM-Dealer Advertising Strategy

Marketing Operations for Better Outcomes

Marketing Operations for Better Outcomes

Dealer vs Manufacturer: Who owns the customer relationship?

Dealer vs Manufacturer: Who owns the customer relationship?


Feed your marketing mind and keep your skills sharp by opting into our newsletter, packed with lessons we’ve learned firsthand. You won’t regret it.